4 January 2024

Choosing the Right Email Marketing Provider

Choosing the Right Email Marketing Provider: A Comprehensive Guide

In today’s digital age, email marketing remains a powerful tool for businesses looking to connect with their audience, build brand loyalty, and boost revenue. 

However, to harness the full potential of email marketing, you need the right email marketing provider. 

In this blog post, we’re going to explore why email marketing is a must, what to look for in an email marketing provider, compare five different options, spill the beans on our Klaviyo partner status, and share a success story of how Yawn Marketing helped one of our key clients soar to new heights.

First things first, why is email marketing important?

Before we dive into selecting the right email marketing provider, let’s briefly explore why email marketing should be an essential part of your digital marketing strategy.

Reach & Engagement: Email marketing lets you reach your audience in their inbox. It’s a personalised and direct way to connect with your subscribers.

Budget-Friendly: It’s cost-effective! Email marketing gives you a big bang for your buck compared to other marketing channels.

Targeted Magic: You can personalise your messages based on your audience’s preferences and journey, ensuring your emails are not snooze-worthy.

Insight Galore: Detailed analytics let you track and improve your campaigns with precision and allow you to improve your approach.

looking over the shoulder of a man at his laptop viewing his email inbox

What to Look for in an Email Marketing Provider?

Now that we understand the importance of email marketing, let’s discuss the essential factors to consider when choosing between email marketing providers:

post-it notes on a wooden surface with various marketing reporting terms written on

Deliverability: Ensure the provider has a strong reputation for delivering emails to inboxes, not spam folders.

Ease of Use: Look for a user-friendly interface, as you want to spend time creating content, not wrestling with complicated tools.

List Management: A good provider should offer tools for building, managing, and segmenting your email list.

Automation: Email automation features are crucial for sending targeted messages, nurturing leads, and saving time.

Templates and Customisation: Access to a library of templates and the ability to customise emails according to your brand’s style is essential.

Analytics and Reporting: Robust analytics help you understand the performance of your campaigns, allowing you to make improvements.

Integrations: Check if the provider integrates with other tools and platforms you use, like e-commerce systems, CRMs, and social media.

Support and Resources: Ensure it offers reliable customer support and a knowledge base for guidance.

Five Email Marketing Providers: Pros and Cons

pink arch with black text saying mailchimp

1. MailChimp:

 Pros:

  • Beginner-friendly with a user-friendly interface.
  • Offers a free plan with basic features.
  • A wide range of integrations for paid plans.

 Cons:

  • Limited automation capabilities.
  • Pricing can become expensive as your list grows.
  • The email editor can be quite restrictive when designing your emails.

2. Constant Contact:

 Pros:

  • Good customer support and resources.
  • Drag-and-drop email editor for easy customisation.
  • Strong list management and segmentation features.

 Cons:

  • Limited automation capabilities compared to some competitors.
  •  Relatively higher pricing for more extensive lists.
green arch with black text saying constant contact
yellow arch with black text saying campaign monitor

3. Campaign Monitor:

 Pros:

  • Beautifully pre-designed email templates.
  • Advanced automation features.
  • Excellent analytics and reporting.

 Cons:

  • It may have a steeper learning curve for beginners.
  • Pricing is on the higher side.

4. GetResponse:

 Pros:

  • Comprehensive email marketing and automation tools.
  • A/B testing for optimising email campaigns.
  • Integration with e-commerce platforms.

  Cons:

  • The user interface might be less intuitive for some users.
  • Limited design flexibility compared to some other platforms.
 
blue arch with black text saying get response
orange arch with black text saying klaviyo

5. Klaviyo:

 Pros:

  • Excellent customer support and resources.
  • Advanced automation, personalisation, and segmentation.
  • Robust analytics, particularly for online stores.
  • Intuitive interface and email builder.
  • It can be integrated with most e-commerce platforms and provides fabulous support when a custom integration is required.
  • A/B testing for optimising email campaigns.

 Cons:

  • Pricing can be higher for businesses with more extensive email lists.

Why we recommend Klaviyo and why we’ve partnered with them

At Yawn Marketing, we understand the importance of choosing the right email marketing provider. That’s why we’re proud to be a Klaviyo partner. Klaviyo is a compelling platform –  an excellent choice for businesses looking to maximise their online sales, utilise their data to the fullest and create carefully tailored and segmented customer journeys. 

Using Klaviyo can take your email marketing to the next level. It lets you craft hyper-personalised and laser-targeted messages that hit the bullseye. With their all-in-one data hub, you can effortlessly automate your marketing strategies across multiple channels, making your workflow a breeze and maximising efficiency.

Partnering with Klaviyo has allowed us to create automation and email campaigns that are so personalised and on-point that you might think we’ve got mind-reading powers! So, if you want to tap into Klaviyo’s superpowers, you know where to find us.

A Real-World Success Story

Hold onto your marketing hats; it’s story time!

Let’s take a look at a real-world example of how Yawn Marketing, in partnership with Klaviyo, has helped an essential email marketing client achieve remarkable growth:

The Client: Red Lobster Gallery

The Red Lobster Gallery team faced the challenge of boosting their e-commerce sales while ensuring seamless alignment between their online presence and physical shop. They aimed to create a cohesive brand experience that resonated with customers across both channels. Bridging the gap between online and offline communications was crucial to maintaining consistency and driving sales.

We tackled this challenge by leveraging Klaviyo’s powerful campaign capabilities and automation features. We crafted targeted Klaviyo campaigns designed to unify Red Lobster Gallery’s online and in-store messaging, ensuring a seamless brand experience for customers. 

We showcased exclusive online offerings through personalised email communications while highlighting the in-store experience. Klaviyo’s automation allowed us to create tailored messages based on customer behaviour, such as abandoned basket reminders, welcome flows, and location-based promotions, driving engagement and conversions. Klaviyo’s tools facilitated the alignment of online communications with the physical store, resulting in a harmonised brand narrative that resonated with customers. 

As a result of our efforts, Red Lobster Gallery saw staggering improvements in its e-commerce performance, with a remarkable 84% increase in year-over-year total sales, a 51% surge in conversion rates, and an astounding 136% growth in year-over-year orders for the month of November 2023.

In this case, combining a powerful email marketing provider like Klaviyo, the expertise of Yawn Marketing and the fabulous products our client has to offer led to tangible results and remarkable business growth for Red Lobster Gallery.

Choosing the right email marketing provider is crucial in your digital marketing strategy

Each provider has unique perks and quirks, and the choice ultimately depends on your specific needs and preferences. 

If you’re looking to harness the full potential of email marketing to grow your business, don’t hesitate to contact us. Remember, the right email marketing provider can be a game-changer for your business and at Yawn Marketing, we’re here to help you make an informed decision.

Contact us if you’re ready to make email marketing magic happen.

No boring answers, no off-the-shelf thinking

Our take on digital marketing trends, updates, tips and tricks.

yawn marketing team members

Celebrating 5 Years of Yawn with 10 Memories

Episode 3: Discussing Leadership

Episode 4: Discussing Process

Episode 5: Discussing Marketing

Episode 6: Looking Back

Blue background with email icons

Google and Yahoo’s new sender requirements

Email icons on screen

Choosing the Right Email Marketing Provider

Optimised Landing Pages: Are you overlooking their value?

How Pinterest can level-up your eCommerce brand

eCommerce Marketing Tips for Jewellery Retailers

5 eCommerce trends to look out for in 2024

Personalised customer experience in the beauty industry

yawn marketing team members

Celebrating 5 Years of Yawn with 10 Memories

Episode 3: Discussing Leadership

Episode 4: Discussing Process

Episode 5: Discussing Marketing

Episode 6: Looking Back

Blue background with email icons

Google and Yahoo’s new sender requirements

Email icons on screen

Choosing the Right Email Marketing Provider

Optimised Landing Pages: Are you overlooking their value?

How Pinterest can level-up your eCommerce brand

eCommerce Marketing Tips for Jewellery Retailers

5 eCommerce trends to look out for in 2024

Personalised customer experience in the beauty industry

Go to previous slide Go to next slide